Files
sunnypilot/selfdrive/selfdrived/events.py
T
DevTekVE ee5c1c4507 Modular Assistive Driving System (MADS) (#446)
* allow re-regage

* bump opendbc

* bump panda

* apply pause/resume fix for hyundai (should do this in a separate PR)

* bump opendbc

* fix

* rename

* Fix?

* make sure to disengage for allow always cars

* fix

* combine

* more fix

* not needed

* check if engagement is from openpilot's state machine

* Rename

* fix panda safety

* fix

* no fake lfa button for @devtekve ;)

* fix non drive gear re-engage

* fix settings

* combine

* add replace method

* use replace

* remoev already checks if it exists

* fix

* group

* add todo

* reserve events

* cleaner

* hyundai: only allow for cars with lfa button

* sunnyParams

* make sure it's car only

* Move car-specific changes to opendbc

* no need

* bump opendbc

* more fixes

* no more available

* more!

* final?

* always emit user disable

* no longer needed

* move unit test

* add sunnypilot to unit tests

* bump opendbc

* use new cereal

* bump opendbc

* static analysis

* no unittest

* no need available

* UI border update

* show MADS updates

* Add TODO

* no longer needed

* fix changed events

* fix cluster enabled

* don't add pre enable if not long

* should use enabled

* enabled <-> active

* better format

* bump opendbc

* static analysis

* static analysis

* Rename test as collector was dying

* Show our overriding

* Revert "show MADS updates"

This reverts commit daf0ad62

Revert "fix changed events"

This reverts commit 31d8c97f

* ignoring reserved events

* adjusting creation delays

* back to stock

removing allow_cancel

* should be enabled

* revert

* silent lkas disable

* no need

* user disable tests

* just warning

* MUST REMOVE test process replay

* fix no entry

* fixme

* bump opendbc

* need this check

* cleanup

* allow entering paused state if no entry from disabled

* brake hold should apply to all

* in lists

* update unit test

* simpler

* unused

* same thing

* fix

* only mads in enabled state and long in disabled state

* unify silent enable

* do this for dlob

* bump submodules

* fix

* bump submodules

* bump opendbc

* less frequent

* more events

* fix

* allow no entry to paused for non-drive gears

* fix

* use cereal

* Revert "allow no entry to paused for non-drive gears"

This reverts commit 6d64a4dd9c.

* allow in all

* Revert "allow in all"

This reverts commit 6375f14891.

* should not be all!

* rename for clarity

* silent park brake

* flipped

* bump submodules

* Bump to latest mads-new panda

* bump panda

* more nissan

* bump panda

* bump msgq

* bump panda

* bump submodules

* bump opendbc

* bump opendbc

* improving the state

* Revert "PlayStation® model (#34133)"

This reverts commit 5160bee543.

* should be none

* bump panda

* bump opendbc

* Apply suggestions from code review

* bump panda

* bump ref panda

* add todo-sp

* bump panda ref

* bump more panda

* changing refs

* nuke nuke nuke

* use sunny's newer states

* bump with new panda

* bump panda

* Parse more flags from alt exp, more tests, hyundai main cruise allowed

* Parse more flags from alt exp, more tests, hyundai main cruise allowed

* missed

* mutation for controls allowed rising edge

* ford mutation

* license

* remove

* unused

* bump submodules

* use always allowed mads button alt exp

* fix

* whitelist jason's lastname to codespell

* test_processes: update ref logs to 82c0278

* bump submodules

* bump submodules

* bump submodules

* bump panda

* add controls mismatch lateral event

* Simplify lateral disengagement logic for MADS configuration

Reversed the conditional to align the logic with the `disengage_lateral_on_brake` parameter. This ensures that lateral disengagement behavior is more intuitive and matches the expected configuration. Improves code readability and reduces potential misconfigurations.

* remove unified engagement mode in panda

* controls allow should be allowed at all times

* squash! treat MADS button as user entry

* heartbeat for mads

* heartbeat mismatch exit control

* remove always allow mads button from alt

* move to safety_mads

* remove main cruise allowed from alt

* bump panda

* heartbeat engaged mads mismatch mutation test

* bump panda

* use mads the third panda

* ignore pre enable with mads

* only force exit if actually actuating

* use brake signal instead of pedal events when dlob is active

* fix tests

* fix panda tests

* bump panda

* new events to retain long blocks

* format

* uem: do not engage mads if long is engaged

* bump submodules

* fix not allowed engaged bug

* block uem from engaging

* flipped

* use different heartbeat check if dlob

* hard code to skip heartbeat check

* remove toyota lta status for lkas, causes weird behaviors

* block tesla

* bump panda

* bump to merged panda

* bump opendbc

* bump opendbc

* bump opendbc

* bump opendbc

* Apply suggestions from code review

* code ignore spells

* needs to be in carstate

* Bump opendbc

* Update MADS toggle descriptions for clarity.

Added notes to clarify behavior of the "MadsMainCruiseAllowed" setting, particularly its impact on vehicles without LFA/LKAS buttons. This ensures users are informed about potential implications when disabling this feature.

* Updating translations + Adding spanish

* Disengage Lateral on Brake -> Pause Lateral on Brake

* test_processes: update ref logs to dd41005

* Apply suggestions from code review

* fix mads button not allowed

* bump submodules

* bump submodule

* test_processes: update ref logs to 0a0b998

* has multiple lists

* Revert "has multiple lists"

This reverts commit a37c1d26fe.

* base

* Reapply "has multiple lists"

This reverts commit d1cd8dcc81.

* migrate mads toggles to sp panel

* this is why it keeps crashing

* house keeping

* more housekeeping

* more housekeeping

* don't show description by default (yet)

* reset to main panel when clicked away

* more

* some more with interactions

* don't stretch cause it looks weird with descriptions

* simpler to handle offroad transition

* some are toggleable while onroad

* remove unused event

* slight cleanup

* default to true for HKG main cruise toggle

* append to list after

* add Customize MADS to UI preview

* simpler

* move to sp list

* how tf was this removed

* update mads settings button on show event

* test_processes: update ref logs to efa9c32

---------

Co-authored-by: Jason Wen <haibin.wen3@gmail.com>
2025-01-04 20:48:02 -05:00

1095 lines
39 KiB
Python
Executable File

#!/usr/bin/env python3
import bisect
import math
import os
from enum import IntEnum
from collections.abc import Callable
from cereal import log, car
import cereal.messaging as messaging
from openpilot.common.conversions import Conversions as CV
from openpilot.common.git import get_short_branch
from openpilot.common.realtime import DT_CTRL
from openpilot.selfdrive.locationd.calibrationd import MIN_SPEED_FILTER
AlertSize = log.SelfdriveState.AlertSize
AlertStatus = log.SelfdriveState.AlertStatus
VisualAlert = car.CarControl.HUDControl.VisualAlert
AudibleAlert = car.CarControl.HUDControl.AudibleAlert
EventName = log.OnroadEvent.EventName
# Alert priorities
class Priority(IntEnum):
LOWEST = 0
LOWER = 1
LOW = 2
MID = 3
HIGH = 4
HIGHEST = 5
# Event types
class ET:
ENABLE = 'enable'
PRE_ENABLE = 'preEnable'
OVERRIDE_LATERAL = 'overrideLateral'
OVERRIDE_LONGITUDINAL = 'overrideLongitudinal'
NO_ENTRY = 'noEntry'
WARNING = 'warning'
USER_DISABLE = 'userDisable'
SOFT_DISABLE = 'softDisable'
IMMEDIATE_DISABLE = 'immediateDisable'
PERMANENT = 'permanent'
# get event name from enum
EVENT_NAME = {v: k for k, v in EventName.schema.enumerants.items()}
class Events:
def __init__(self):
self.events: list[int] = []
self.static_events: list[int] = []
self.event_counters = dict.fromkeys(EVENTS.keys(), 0)
@property
def names(self) -> list[int]:
return self.events
def __len__(self) -> int:
return len(self.events)
def add(self, event_name: int, static: bool=False) -> None:
if static:
bisect.insort(self.static_events, event_name)
bisect.insort(self.events, event_name)
def clear(self) -> None:
self.event_counters = {k: (v + 1 if k in self.events else 0) for k, v in self.event_counters.items()}
self.events = self.static_events.copy()
def contains(self, event_type: str) -> bool:
return any(event_type in EVENTS.get(e, {}) for e in self.events)
def create_alerts(self, event_types: list[str], callback_args=None):
if callback_args is None:
callback_args = []
ret = []
for e in self.events:
types = EVENTS[e].keys()
for et in event_types:
if et in types:
alert = EVENTS[e][et]
if not isinstance(alert, Alert):
alert = alert(*callback_args)
if DT_CTRL * (self.event_counters[e] + 1) >= alert.creation_delay:
alert.alert_type = f"{EVENT_NAME[e]}/{et}"
alert.event_type = et
ret.append(alert)
return ret
def add_from_msg(self, events):
for e in events:
bisect.insort(self.events, e.name.raw)
def to_msg(self):
ret = []
for event_name in self.events:
event = log.OnroadEvent.new_message()
event.name = event_name
for event_type in EVENTS.get(event_name, {}):
setattr(event, event_type, True)
ret.append(event)
return ret
def has(self, event_name: int) -> bool:
return event_name in self.events
def contains_in_list(self, events_list: list[int]) -> bool:
return any(event_name in self.events for event_name in events_list)
def remove(self, event_name: int, static: bool = False) -> None:
if static and event_name in self.static_events:
self.static_events.remove(event_name)
if event_name in self.events:
self.event_counters[event_name] = self.event_counters[event_name] + 1
self.events.remove(event_name)
def replace(self, prev_event_name: int, cur_event_name: int, static: bool = False) -> None:
self.remove(prev_event_name, static)
self.add(cur_event_name, static)
class Alert:
def __init__(self,
alert_text_1: str,
alert_text_2: str,
alert_status: log.SelfdriveState.AlertStatus,
alert_size: log.SelfdriveState.AlertSize,
priority: Priority,
visual_alert: car.CarControl.HUDControl.VisualAlert,
audible_alert: car.CarControl.HUDControl.AudibleAlert,
duration: float,
creation_delay: float = 0.):
self.alert_text_1 = alert_text_1
self.alert_text_2 = alert_text_2
self.alert_status = alert_status
self.alert_size = alert_size
self.priority = priority
self.visual_alert = visual_alert
self.audible_alert = audible_alert
self.duration = int(duration / DT_CTRL)
self.creation_delay = creation_delay
self.alert_type = ""
self.event_type: str | None = None
def __str__(self) -> str:
return f"{self.alert_text_1}/{self.alert_text_2} {self.priority} {self.visual_alert} {self.audible_alert}"
def __gt__(self, alert2) -> bool:
if not isinstance(alert2, Alert):
return False
return self.priority > alert2.priority
EmptyAlert = Alert("" , "", AlertStatus.normal, AlertSize.none, Priority.LOWEST,
VisualAlert.none, AudibleAlert.none, 0)
class NoEntryAlert(Alert):
def __init__(self, alert_text_2: str,
alert_text_1: str = "openpilot Unavailable",
visual_alert: car.CarControl.HUDControl.VisualAlert=VisualAlert.none):
super().__init__(alert_text_1, alert_text_2, AlertStatus.normal,
AlertSize.mid, Priority.LOW, visual_alert,
AudibleAlert.refuse, 3.)
class SoftDisableAlert(Alert):
def __init__(self, alert_text_2: str):
super().__init__("TAKE CONTROL IMMEDIATELY", alert_text_2,
AlertStatus.userPrompt, AlertSize.full,
Priority.MID, VisualAlert.steerRequired,
AudibleAlert.warningSoft, 2.),
# less harsh version of SoftDisable, where the condition is user-triggered
class UserSoftDisableAlert(SoftDisableAlert):
def __init__(self, alert_text_2: str):
super().__init__(alert_text_2),
self.alert_text_1 = "openpilot will disengage"
class ImmediateDisableAlert(Alert):
def __init__(self, alert_text_2: str):
super().__init__("TAKE CONTROL IMMEDIATELY", alert_text_2,
AlertStatus.critical, AlertSize.full,
Priority.HIGHEST, VisualAlert.steerRequired,
AudibleAlert.warningImmediate, 4.),
class EngagementAlert(Alert):
def __init__(self, audible_alert: car.CarControl.HUDControl.AudibleAlert):
super().__init__("", "",
AlertStatus.normal, AlertSize.none,
Priority.MID, VisualAlert.none,
audible_alert, .2),
class NormalPermanentAlert(Alert):
def __init__(self, alert_text_1: str, alert_text_2: str = "", duration: float = 0.2, priority: Priority = Priority.LOWER, creation_delay: float = 0.):
super().__init__(alert_text_1, alert_text_2,
AlertStatus.normal, AlertSize.mid if len(alert_text_2) else AlertSize.small,
priority, VisualAlert.none, AudibleAlert.none, duration, creation_delay=creation_delay),
class StartupAlert(Alert):
def __init__(self, alert_text_1: str, alert_text_2: str = "Always keep hands on wheel and eyes on road", alert_status=AlertStatus.normal):
super().__init__(alert_text_1, alert_text_2,
alert_status, AlertSize.mid,
Priority.LOWER, VisualAlert.none, AudibleAlert.none, 5.),
# ********** helper functions **********
def get_display_speed(speed_ms: float, metric: bool) -> str:
speed = int(round(speed_ms * (CV.MS_TO_KPH if metric else CV.MS_TO_MPH)))
unit = 'km/h' if metric else 'mph'
return f"{speed} {unit}"
# ********** alert callback functions **********
AlertCallbackType = Callable[[car.CarParams, car.CarState, messaging.SubMaster, bool, int, log.ControlsState], Alert]
def soft_disable_alert(alert_text_2: str) -> AlertCallbackType:
def func(CP: car.CarParams, CS: car.CarState, sm: messaging.SubMaster, metric: bool, soft_disable_time: int, personality) -> Alert:
if soft_disable_time < int(0.5 / DT_CTRL):
return ImmediateDisableAlert(alert_text_2)
return SoftDisableAlert(alert_text_2)
return func
def user_soft_disable_alert(alert_text_2: str) -> AlertCallbackType:
def func(CP: car.CarParams, CS: car.CarState, sm: messaging.SubMaster, metric: bool, soft_disable_time: int, personality) -> Alert:
if soft_disable_time < int(0.5 / DT_CTRL):
return ImmediateDisableAlert(alert_text_2)
return UserSoftDisableAlert(alert_text_2)
return func
def startup_master_alert(CP: car.CarParams, CS: car.CarState, sm: messaging.SubMaster, metric: bool, soft_disable_time: int, personality) -> Alert:
branch = get_short_branch() # Ensure get_short_branch is cached to avoid lags on startup
if "REPLAY" in os.environ:
branch = "replay"
return StartupAlert("WARNING: This branch is not tested", branch, alert_status=AlertStatus.userPrompt)
def below_engage_speed_alert(CP: car.CarParams, CS: car.CarState, sm: messaging.SubMaster, metric: bool, soft_disable_time: int, personality) -> Alert:
return NoEntryAlert(f"Drive above {get_display_speed(CP.minEnableSpeed, metric)} to engage")
def below_steer_speed_alert(CP: car.CarParams, CS: car.CarState, sm: messaging.SubMaster, metric: bool, soft_disable_time: int, personality) -> Alert:
return Alert(
f"Steer Unavailable Below {get_display_speed(CP.minSteerSpeed, metric)}",
"",
AlertStatus.userPrompt, AlertSize.small,
Priority.LOW, VisualAlert.steerRequired, AudibleAlert.prompt, 0.4)
def calibration_incomplete_alert(CP: car.CarParams, CS: car.CarState, sm: messaging.SubMaster, metric: bool, soft_disable_time: int, personality) -> Alert:
first_word = 'Recalibration' if sm['liveCalibration'].calStatus == log.LiveCalibrationData.Status.recalibrating else 'Calibration'
return Alert(
f"{first_word} in Progress: {sm['liveCalibration'].calPerc:.0f}%",
f"Drive Above {get_display_speed(MIN_SPEED_FILTER, metric)}",
AlertStatus.normal, AlertSize.mid,
Priority.LOWEST, VisualAlert.none, AudibleAlert.none, .2)
# *** debug alerts ***
def out_of_space_alert(CP: car.CarParams, CS: car.CarState, sm: messaging.SubMaster, metric: bool, soft_disable_time: int, personality) -> Alert:
full_perc = round(100. - sm['deviceState'].freeSpacePercent)
return NormalPermanentAlert("Out of Storage", f"{full_perc}% full")
def posenet_invalid_alert(CP: car.CarParams, CS: car.CarState, sm: messaging.SubMaster, metric: bool, soft_disable_time: int, personality) -> Alert:
mdl = sm['modelV2'].velocity.x[0] if len(sm['modelV2'].velocity.x) else math.nan
err = CS.vEgo - mdl
msg = f"Speed Error: {err:.1f} m/s"
return NoEntryAlert(msg, alert_text_1="Posenet Speed Invalid")
def process_not_running_alert(CP: car.CarParams, CS: car.CarState, sm: messaging.SubMaster, metric: bool, soft_disable_time: int, personality) -> Alert:
not_running = [p.name for p in sm['managerState'].processes if not p.running and p.shouldBeRunning]
msg = ', '.join(not_running)
return NoEntryAlert(msg, alert_text_1="Process Not Running")
def comm_issue_alert(CP: car.CarParams, CS: car.CarState, sm: messaging.SubMaster, metric: bool, soft_disable_time: int, personality) -> Alert:
bs = [s for s in sm.data.keys() if not sm.all_checks([s, ])]
msg = ', '.join(bs[:4]) # can't fit too many on one line
return NoEntryAlert(msg, alert_text_1="Communication Issue Between Processes")
def camera_malfunction_alert(CP: car.CarParams, CS: car.CarState, sm: messaging.SubMaster, metric: bool, soft_disable_time: int, personality) -> Alert:
all_cams = ('roadCameraState', 'driverCameraState', 'wideRoadCameraState')
bad_cams = [s.replace('State', '') for s in all_cams if s in sm.data.keys() and not sm.all_checks([s, ])]
return NormalPermanentAlert("Camera Malfunction", ', '.join(bad_cams))
def calibration_invalid_alert(CP: car.CarParams, CS: car.CarState, sm: messaging.SubMaster, metric: bool, soft_disable_time: int, personality) -> Alert:
rpy = sm['liveCalibration'].rpyCalib
yaw = math.degrees(rpy[2] if len(rpy) == 3 else math.nan)
pitch = math.degrees(rpy[1] if len(rpy) == 3 else math.nan)
angles = f"Remount Device (Pitch: {pitch:.1f}°, Yaw: {yaw:.1f}°)"
return NormalPermanentAlert("Calibration Invalid", angles)
def overheat_alert(CP: car.CarParams, CS: car.CarState, sm: messaging.SubMaster, metric: bool, soft_disable_time: int, personality) -> Alert:
cpu = max(sm['deviceState'].cpuTempC, default=0.)
gpu = max(sm['deviceState'].gpuTempC, default=0.)
temp = max((cpu, gpu, sm['deviceState'].memoryTempC))
return NormalPermanentAlert("System Overheated", f"{temp:.0f} °C")
def low_memory_alert(CP: car.CarParams, CS: car.CarState, sm: messaging.SubMaster, metric: bool, soft_disable_time: int, personality) -> Alert:
return NormalPermanentAlert("Low Memory", f"{sm['deviceState'].memoryUsagePercent}% used")
def high_cpu_usage_alert(CP: car.CarParams, CS: car.CarState, sm: messaging.SubMaster, metric: bool, soft_disable_time: int, personality) -> Alert:
x = max(sm['deviceState'].cpuUsagePercent, default=0.)
return NormalPermanentAlert("High CPU Usage", f"{x}% used")
def modeld_lagging_alert(CP: car.CarParams, CS: car.CarState, sm: messaging.SubMaster, metric: bool, soft_disable_time: int, personality) -> Alert:
return NormalPermanentAlert("Driving Model Lagging", f"{sm['modelV2'].frameDropPerc:.1f}% frames dropped")
def wrong_car_mode_alert(CP: car.CarParams, CS: car.CarState, sm: messaging.SubMaster, metric: bool, soft_disable_time: int, personality) -> Alert:
text = "Enable Adaptive Cruise to Engage"
if CP.carName == "honda":
text = "Enable Main Switch to Engage"
return NoEntryAlert(text)
def joystick_alert(CP: car.CarParams, CS: car.CarState, sm: messaging.SubMaster, metric: bool, soft_disable_time: int, personality) -> Alert:
gb = sm['carControl'].actuators.accel / 4.
steer = sm['carControl'].actuators.steer
vals = f"Gas: {round(gb * 100.)}%, Steer: {round(steer * 100.)}%"
return NormalPermanentAlert("Joystick Mode", vals)
def longitudinal_maneuver_alert(CP: car.CarParams, CS: car.CarState, sm: messaging.SubMaster, metric: bool, soft_disable_time: int, personality) -> Alert:
ad = sm['alertDebug']
audible_alert = AudibleAlert.prompt if 'Active' in ad.alertText1 else AudibleAlert.none
alert_status = AlertStatus.userPrompt if 'Active' in ad.alertText1 else AlertStatus.normal
alert_size = AlertSize.mid if ad.alertText2 else AlertSize.small
return Alert(ad.alertText1, ad.alertText2,
alert_status, alert_size,
Priority.LOW, VisualAlert.none, audible_alert, 0.2)
def personality_changed_alert(CP: car.CarParams, CS: car.CarState, sm: messaging.SubMaster, metric: bool, soft_disable_time: int, personality) -> Alert:
personality = str(personality).title()
return NormalPermanentAlert(f"Driving Personality: {personality}", duration=1.5)
EVENTS: dict[int, dict[str, Alert | AlertCallbackType]] = {
# ********** events with no alerts **********
EventName.stockFcw: {},
EventName.actuatorsApiUnavailable: {},
# ********** events only containing alerts displayed in all states **********
EventName.joystickDebug: {
ET.WARNING: joystick_alert,
ET.PERMANENT: NormalPermanentAlert("Joystick Mode"),
},
EventName.longitudinalManeuver: {
ET.WARNING: longitudinal_maneuver_alert,
ET.PERMANENT: NormalPermanentAlert("Longitudinal Maneuver Mode",
"Ensure road ahead is clear"),
},
EventName.selfdriveInitializing: {
ET.NO_ENTRY: NoEntryAlert("System Initializing"),
},
EventName.startup: {
ET.PERMANENT: StartupAlert("Be ready to take over at any time")
},
EventName.startupMaster: {
ET.PERMANENT: startup_master_alert,
},
EventName.startupNoControl: {
ET.PERMANENT: StartupAlert("Dashcam mode"),
ET.NO_ENTRY: NoEntryAlert("Dashcam mode"),
},
EventName.startupNoCar: {
ET.PERMANENT: StartupAlert("Dashcam mode for unsupported car"),
},
EventName.startupNoSecOcKey: {
ET.PERMANENT: NormalPermanentAlert("Dashcam Mode",
"Security Key Not Available",
priority=Priority.HIGH),
},
EventName.dashcamMode: {
ET.PERMANENT: NormalPermanentAlert("Dashcam Mode",
priority=Priority.LOWEST),
},
EventName.invalidLkasSetting: {
ET.PERMANENT: NormalPermanentAlert("Invalid LKAS setting",
"Toggle stock LKAS on or off to engage"),
ET.NO_ENTRY: NoEntryAlert("Invalid LKAS setting"),
},
EventName.cruiseMismatch: {
#ET.PERMANENT: ImmediateDisableAlert("openpilot failed to cancel cruise"),
},
# openpilot doesn't recognize the car. This switches openpilot into a
# read-only mode. This can be solved by adding your fingerprint.
# See https://github.com/commaai/openpilot/wiki/Fingerprinting for more information
EventName.carUnrecognized: {
ET.PERMANENT: NormalPermanentAlert("Dashcam Mode",
"Car Unrecognized",
priority=Priority.LOWEST),
},
EventName.aeb: {
ET.PERMANENT: Alert(
"BRAKE!",
"Emergency Braking: Risk of Collision",
AlertStatus.critical, AlertSize.full,
Priority.HIGHEST, VisualAlert.fcw, AudibleAlert.none, 2.),
ET.NO_ENTRY: NoEntryAlert("AEB: Risk of Collision"),
},
EventName.stockAeb: {
ET.PERMANENT: Alert(
"BRAKE!",
"Stock AEB: Risk of Collision",
AlertStatus.critical, AlertSize.full,
Priority.HIGHEST, VisualAlert.fcw, AudibleAlert.none, 2.),
ET.NO_ENTRY: NoEntryAlert("Stock AEB: Risk of Collision"),
},
EventName.fcw: {
ET.PERMANENT: Alert(
"BRAKE!",
"Risk of Collision",
AlertStatus.critical, AlertSize.full,
Priority.HIGHEST, VisualAlert.fcw, AudibleAlert.warningSoft, 2.),
},
EventName.ldw: {
ET.PERMANENT: Alert(
"Lane Departure Detected",
"",
AlertStatus.userPrompt, AlertSize.small,
Priority.LOW, VisualAlert.ldw, AudibleAlert.prompt, 3.),
},
# ********** events only containing alerts that display while engaged **********
EventName.steerTempUnavailableSilent: {
ET.WARNING: Alert(
"Steering Temporarily Unavailable",
"",
AlertStatus.userPrompt, AlertSize.small,
Priority.LOW, VisualAlert.steerRequired, AudibleAlert.prompt, 1.8),
},
EventName.preDriverDistracted: {
ET.PERMANENT: Alert(
"Pay Attention",
"",
AlertStatus.normal, AlertSize.small,
Priority.LOW, VisualAlert.none, AudibleAlert.none, .1),
},
EventName.promptDriverDistracted: {
ET.PERMANENT: Alert(
"Pay Attention",
"Driver Distracted",
AlertStatus.userPrompt, AlertSize.mid,
Priority.MID, VisualAlert.steerRequired, AudibleAlert.promptDistracted, .1),
},
EventName.driverDistracted: {
ET.PERMANENT: Alert(
"DISENGAGE IMMEDIATELY",
"Driver Distracted",
AlertStatus.critical, AlertSize.full,
Priority.HIGH, VisualAlert.steerRequired, AudibleAlert.warningImmediate, .1),
},
EventName.preDriverUnresponsive: {
ET.PERMANENT: Alert(
"Touch Steering Wheel: No Face Detected",
"",
AlertStatus.normal, AlertSize.small,
Priority.LOW, VisualAlert.steerRequired, AudibleAlert.none, .1),
},
EventName.promptDriverUnresponsive: {
ET.PERMANENT: Alert(
"Touch Steering Wheel",
"Driver Unresponsive",
AlertStatus.userPrompt, AlertSize.mid,
Priority.MID, VisualAlert.steerRequired, AudibleAlert.promptDistracted, .1),
},
EventName.driverUnresponsive: {
ET.PERMANENT: Alert(
"DISENGAGE IMMEDIATELY",
"Driver Unresponsive",
AlertStatus.critical, AlertSize.full,
Priority.HIGH, VisualAlert.steerRequired, AudibleAlert.warningImmediate, .1),
},
EventName.manualRestart: {
ET.WARNING: Alert(
"TAKE CONTROL",
"Resume Driving Manually",
AlertStatus.userPrompt, AlertSize.mid,
Priority.LOW, VisualAlert.none, AudibleAlert.none, .2),
},
EventName.resumeRequired: {
ET.WARNING: Alert(
"Press Resume to Exit Standstill",
"",
AlertStatus.userPrompt, AlertSize.small,
Priority.LOW, VisualAlert.none, AudibleAlert.none, .2),
},
EventName.belowSteerSpeed: {
ET.WARNING: below_steer_speed_alert,
},
EventName.preLaneChangeLeft: {
ET.WARNING: Alert(
"Steer Left to Start Lane Change Once Safe",
"",
AlertStatus.normal, AlertSize.small,
Priority.LOW, VisualAlert.none, AudibleAlert.none, .1),
},
EventName.preLaneChangeRight: {
ET.WARNING: Alert(
"Steer Right to Start Lane Change Once Safe",
"",
AlertStatus.normal, AlertSize.small,
Priority.LOW, VisualAlert.none, AudibleAlert.none, .1),
},
EventName.laneChangeBlocked: {
ET.WARNING: Alert(
"Car Detected in Blindspot",
"",
AlertStatus.userPrompt, AlertSize.small,
Priority.LOW, VisualAlert.none, AudibleAlert.prompt, .1),
},
EventName.laneChange: {
ET.WARNING: Alert(
"Changing Lanes",
"",
AlertStatus.normal, AlertSize.small,
Priority.LOW, VisualAlert.none, AudibleAlert.none, .1),
},
EventName.steerSaturated: {
ET.WARNING: Alert(
"Take Control",
"Turn Exceeds Steering Limit",
AlertStatus.userPrompt, AlertSize.mid,
Priority.LOW, VisualAlert.steerRequired, AudibleAlert.promptRepeat, 2.),
},
# Thrown when the fan is driven at >50% but is not rotating
EventName.fanMalfunction: {
ET.PERMANENT: NormalPermanentAlert("Fan Malfunction", "Likely Hardware Issue"),
},
# Camera is not outputting frames
EventName.cameraMalfunction: {
ET.PERMANENT: camera_malfunction_alert,
ET.SOFT_DISABLE: soft_disable_alert("Camera Malfunction"),
ET.NO_ENTRY: NoEntryAlert("Camera Malfunction: Reboot Your Device"),
},
# Camera framerate too low
EventName.cameraFrameRate: {
ET.PERMANENT: NormalPermanentAlert("Camera Frame Rate Low", "Reboot your Device"),
ET.SOFT_DISABLE: soft_disable_alert("Camera Frame Rate Low"),
ET.NO_ENTRY: NoEntryAlert("Camera Frame Rate Low: Reboot Your Device"),
},
# Unused
EventName.locationdTemporaryError: {
ET.NO_ENTRY: NoEntryAlert("locationd Temporary Error"),
ET.SOFT_DISABLE: soft_disable_alert("locationd Temporary Error"),
},
EventName.locationdPermanentError: {
ET.NO_ENTRY: NoEntryAlert("locationd Permanent Error"),
ET.IMMEDIATE_DISABLE: ImmediateDisableAlert("locationd Permanent Error"),
ET.PERMANENT: NormalPermanentAlert("locationd Permanent Error"),
},
# openpilot tries to learn certain parameters about your car by observing
# how the car behaves to steering inputs from both human and openpilot driving.
# This includes:
# - steer ratio: gear ratio of the steering rack. Steering angle divided by tire angle
# - tire stiffness: how much grip your tires have
# - angle offset: most steering angle sensors are offset and measure a non zero angle when driving straight
# This alert is thrown when any of these values exceed a sanity check. This can be caused by
# bad alignment or bad sensor data. If this happens consistently consider creating an issue on GitHub
EventName.paramsdTemporaryError: {
ET.NO_ENTRY: NoEntryAlert("paramsd Temporary Error"),
ET.SOFT_DISABLE: soft_disable_alert("paramsd Temporary Error"),
},
EventName.paramsdPermanentError: {
ET.NO_ENTRY: NoEntryAlert("paramsd Permanent Error"),
ET.IMMEDIATE_DISABLE: ImmediateDisableAlert("paramsd Permanent Error"),
ET.PERMANENT: NormalPermanentAlert("paramsd Permanent Error"),
},
# ********** events that affect controls state transitions **********
EventName.pcmEnable: {
ET.ENABLE: EngagementAlert(AudibleAlert.engage),
},
EventName.buttonEnable: {
ET.ENABLE: EngagementAlert(AudibleAlert.engage),
},
EventName.pcmDisable: {
ET.USER_DISABLE: EngagementAlert(AudibleAlert.disengage),
},
EventName.buttonCancel: {
ET.USER_DISABLE: EngagementAlert(AudibleAlert.disengage),
ET.NO_ENTRY: NoEntryAlert("Cancel Pressed"),
},
EventName.brakeHold: {
ET.USER_DISABLE: EngagementAlert(AudibleAlert.disengage),
ET.NO_ENTRY: NoEntryAlert("Brake Hold Active"),
},
EventName.parkBrake: {
ET.USER_DISABLE: EngagementAlert(AudibleAlert.disengage),
ET.NO_ENTRY: NoEntryAlert("Parking Brake Engaged"),
},
EventName.pedalPressed: {
ET.USER_DISABLE: EngagementAlert(AudibleAlert.disengage),
ET.NO_ENTRY: NoEntryAlert("Pedal Pressed",
visual_alert=VisualAlert.brakePressed),
},
EventName.preEnableStandstill: {
ET.PRE_ENABLE: Alert(
"Release Brake to Engage",
"",
AlertStatus.normal, AlertSize.small,
Priority.LOWEST, VisualAlert.none, AudibleAlert.none, .1, creation_delay=1.),
},
EventName.gasPressedOverride: {
ET.OVERRIDE_LONGITUDINAL: Alert(
"",
"",
AlertStatus.normal, AlertSize.none,
Priority.LOWEST, VisualAlert.none, AudibleAlert.none, .1),
},
EventName.steerOverride: {
ET.OVERRIDE_LATERAL: Alert(
"",
"",
AlertStatus.normal, AlertSize.none,
Priority.LOWEST, VisualAlert.none, AudibleAlert.none, .1),
},
EventName.wrongCarMode: {
ET.USER_DISABLE: EngagementAlert(AudibleAlert.disengage),
ET.NO_ENTRY: wrong_car_mode_alert,
},
EventName.resumeBlocked: {
ET.NO_ENTRY: NoEntryAlert("Press Set to Engage"),
},
EventName.wrongCruiseMode: {
ET.USER_DISABLE: EngagementAlert(AudibleAlert.disengage),
ET.NO_ENTRY: NoEntryAlert("Adaptive Cruise Disabled"),
},
EventName.steerTempUnavailable: {
ET.SOFT_DISABLE: soft_disable_alert("Steering Temporarily Unavailable"),
ET.NO_ENTRY: NoEntryAlert("Steering Temporarily Unavailable"),
},
EventName.steerTimeLimit: {
ET.SOFT_DISABLE: soft_disable_alert("Vehicle Steering Time Limit"),
ET.NO_ENTRY: NoEntryAlert("Vehicle Steering Time Limit"),
},
EventName.outOfSpace: {
ET.PERMANENT: out_of_space_alert,
ET.NO_ENTRY: NoEntryAlert("Out of Storage"),
},
EventName.belowEngageSpeed: {
ET.NO_ENTRY: below_engage_speed_alert,
},
EventName.sensorDataInvalid: {
ET.PERMANENT: Alert(
"Sensor Data Invalid",
"Possible Hardware Issue",
AlertStatus.normal, AlertSize.mid,
Priority.LOWER, VisualAlert.none, AudibleAlert.none, .2, creation_delay=1.),
ET.NO_ENTRY: NoEntryAlert("Sensor Data Invalid"),
ET.SOFT_DISABLE: soft_disable_alert("Sensor Data Invalid"),
},
EventName.noGps: {
ET.PERMANENT: Alert(
"Poor GPS reception",
"Ensure device has a clear view of the sky",
AlertStatus.normal, AlertSize.mid,
Priority.LOWER, VisualAlert.none, AudibleAlert.none, .2, creation_delay=600.)
},
EventName.tooDistracted: {
ET.NO_ENTRY: NoEntryAlert("Distraction Level Too High"),
},
EventName.overheat: {
ET.PERMANENT: overheat_alert,
ET.SOFT_DISABLE: soft_disable_alert("System Overheated"),
ET.NO_ENTRY: NoEntryAlert("System Overheated"),
},
EventName.wrongGear: {
ET.SOFT_DISABLE: user_soft_disable_alert("Gear not D"),
ET.NO_ENTRY: NoEntryAlert("Gear not D"),
},
# This alert is thrown when the calibration angles are outside of the acceptable range.
# For example if the device is pointed too much to the left or the right.
# Usually this can only be solved by removing the mount from the windshield completely,
# and attaching while making sure the device is pointed straight forward and is level.
# See https://comma.ai/setup for more information
EventName.calibrationInvalid: {
ET.PERMANENT: calibration_invalid_alert,
ET.SOFT_DISABLE: soft_disable_alert("Calibration Invalid: Remount Device & Recalibrate"),
ET.NO_ENTRY: NoEntryAlert("Calibration Invalid: Remount Device & Recalibrate"),
},
EventName.calibrationIncomplete: {
ET.PERMANENT: calibration_incomplete_alert,
ET.SOFT_DISABLE: soft_disable_alert("Calibration Incomplete"),
ET.NO_ENTRY: NoEntryAlert("Calibration in Progress"),
},
EventName.calibrationRecalibrating: {
ET.PERMANENT: calibration_incomplete_alert,
ET.SOFT_DISABLE: soft_disable_alert("Device Remount Detected: Recalibrating"),
ET.NO_ENTRY: NoEntryAlert("Remount Detected: Recalibrating"),
},
EventName.doorOpen: {
ET.SOFT_DISABLE: user_soft_disable_alert("Door Open"),
ET.NO_ENTRY: NoEntryAlert("Door Open"),
},
EventName.seatbeltNotLatched: {
ET.SOFT_DISABLE: user_soft_disable_alert("Seatbelt Unlatched"),
ET.NO_ENTRY: NoEntryAlert("Seatbelt Unlatched"),
},
EventName.espDisabled: {
ET.SOFT_DISABLE: soft_disable_alert("Electronic Stability Control Disabled"),
ET.NO_ENTRY: NoEntryAlert("Electronic Stability Control Disabled"),
},
EventName.lowBattery: {
ET.SOFT_DISABLE: soft_disable_alert("Low Battery"),
ET.NO_ENTRY: NoEntryAlert("Low Battery"),
},
# Different openpilot services communicate between each other at a certain
# interval. If communication does not follow the regular schedule this alert
# is thrown. This can mean a service crashed, did not broadcast a message for
# ten times the regular interval, or the average interval is more than 10% too high.
EventName.commIssue: {
ET.SOFT_DISABLE: soft_disable_alert("Communication Issue Between Processes"),
ET.NO_ENTRY: comm_issue_alert,
},
EventName.commIssueAvgFreq: {
ET.SOFT_DISABLE: soft_disable_alert("Low Communication Rate Between Processes"),
ET.NO_ENTRY: NoEntryAlert("Low Communication Rate Between Processes"),
},
EventName.selfdrivedLagging: {
ET.SOFT_DISABLE: soft_disable_alert("System Lagging"),
ET.NO_ENTRY: NoEntryAlert("Selfdrive Process Lagging: Reboot Your Device"),
},
# Thrown when manager detects a service exited unexpectedly while driving
EventName.processNotRunning: {
ET.NO_ENTRY: process_not_running_alert,
ET.SOFT_DISABLE: soft_disable_alert("Process Not Running"),
},
EventName.radarFault: {
ET.SOFT_DISABLE: soft_disable_alert("Radar Error: Restart the Car"),
ET.NO_ENTRY: NoEntryAlert("Radar Error: Restart the Car"),
},
# Every frame from the camera should be processed by the model. If modeld
# is not processing frames fast enough they have to be dropped. This alert is
# thrown when over 20% of frames are dropped.
EventName.modeldLagging: {
ET.SOFT_DISABLE: soft_disable_alert("Driving Model Lagging"),
ET.NO_ENTRY: NoEntryAlert("Driving Model Lagging"),
ET.PERMANENT: modeld_lagging_alert,
},
# Besides predicting the path, lane lines and lead car data the model also
# predicts the current velocity and rotation speed of the car. If the model is
# very uncertain about the current velocity while the car is moving, this
# usually means the model has trouble understanding the scene. This is used
# as a heuristic to warn the driver.
EventName.posenetInvalid: {
ET.SOFT_DISABLE: soft_disable_alert("Posenet Speed Invalid"),
ET.NO_ENTRY: posenet_invalid_alert,
},
# When the localizer detects an acceleration of more than 40 m/s^2 (~4G) we
# alert the driver the device might have fallen from the windshield.
EventName.deviceFalling: {
ET.SOFT_DISABLE: soft_disable_alert("Device Fell Off Mount"),
ET.NO_ENTRY: NoEntryAlert("Device Fell Off Mount"),
},
EventName.lowMemory: {
ET.SOFT_DISABLE: soft_disable_alert("Low Memory: Reboot Your Device"),
ET.PERMANENT: low_memory_alert,
ET.NO_ENTRY: NoEntryAlert("Low Memory: Reboot Your Device"),
},
EventName.accFaulted: {
ET.IMMEDIATE_DISABLE: ImmediateDisableAlert("Cruise Fault: Restart the Car"),
ET.PERMANENT: NormalPermanentAlert("Cruise Fault: Restart the car to engage"),
ET.NO_ENTRY: NoEntryAlert("Cruise Fault: Restart the Car"),
},
EventName.espActive: {
ET.SOFT_DISABLE: soft_disable_alert("Electronic Stability Control Active"),
ET.NO_ENTRY: NoEntryAlert("Electronic Stability Control Active"),
},
EventName.controlsMismatch: {
ET.IMMEDIATE_DISABLE: ImmediateDisableAlert("Controls Mismatch"),
ET.NO_ENTRY: NoEntryAlert("Controls Mismatch"),
},
# Sometimes the USB stack on the device can get into a bad state
# causing the connection to the panda to be lost
EventName.usbError: {
ET.SOFT_DISABLE: soft_disable_alert("USB Error: Reboot Your Device"),
ET.PERMANENT: NormalPermanentAlert("USB Error: Reboot Your Device", ""),
ET.NO_ENTRY: NoEntryAlert("USB Error: Reboot Your Device"),
},
# This alert can be thrown for the following reasons:
# - No CAN data received at all
# - CAN data is received, but some message are not received at the right frequency
# If you're not writing a new car port, this is usually cause by faulty wiring
EventName.canError: {
ET.IMMEDIATE_DISABLE: ImmediateDisableAlert("CAN Error"),
ET.PERMANENT: Alert(
"CAN Error: Check Connections",
"",
AlertStatus.normal, AlertSize.small,
Priority.LOW, VisualAlert.none, AudibleAlert.none, 1., creation_delay=1.),
ET.NO_ENTRY: NoEntryAlert("CAN Error: Check Connections"),
},
EventName.canBusMissing: {
ET.IMMEDIATE_DISABLE: ImmediateDisableAlert("CAN Bus Disconnected"),
ET.PERMANENT: Alert(
"CAN Bus Disconnected: Likely Faulty Cable",
"",
AlertStatus.normal, AlertSize.small,
Priority.LOW, VisualAlert.none, AudibleAlert.none, 1., creation_delay=1.),
ET.NO_ENTRY: NoEntryAlert("CAN Bus Disconnected: Check Connections"),
},
EventName.steerUnavailable: {
ET.IMMEDIATE_DISABLE: ImmediateDisableAlert("LKAS Fault: Restart the Car"),
ET.PERMANENT: NormalPermanentAlert("LKAS Fault: Restart the car to engage"),
ET.NO_ENTRY: NoEntryAlert("LKAS Fault: Restart the Car"),
},
EventName.reverseGear: {
ET.PERMANENT: Alert(
"Reverse\nGear",
"",
AlertStatus.normal, AlertSize.full,
Priority.LOWEST, VisualAlert.none, AudibleAlert.none, .2, creation_delay=0.5),
ET.USER_DISABLE: ImmediateDisableAlert("Reverse Gear"),
ET.NO_ENTRY: NoEntryAlert("Reverse Gear"),
},
# On cars that use stock ACC the car can decide to cancel ACC for various reasons.
# When this happens we can no long control the car so the user needs to be warned immediately.
EventName.cruiseDisabled: {
ET.IMMEDIATE_DISABLE: ImmediateDisableAlert("Cruise Is Off"),
},
# When the relay in the harness box opens the CAN bus between the LKAS camera
# and the rest of the car is separated. When messages from the LKAS camera
# are received on the car side this usually means the relay hasn't opened correctly
# and this alert is thrown.
EventName.relayMalfunction: {
ET.IMMEDIATE_DISABLE: ImmediateDisableAlert("Harness Relay Malfunction"),
ET.PERMANENT: NormalPermanentAlert("Harness Relay Malfunction", "Check Hardware"),
ET.NO_ENTRY: NoEntryAlert("Harness Relay Malfunction"),
},
EventName.speedTooLow: {
ET.IMMEDIATE_DISABLE: Alert(
"openpilot Canceled",
"Speed too low",
AlertStatus.normal, AlertSize.mid,
Priority.HIGH, VisualAlert.none, AudibleAlert.disengage, 3.),
},
# When the car is driving faster than most cars in the training data, the model outputs can be unpredictable.
EventName.speedTooHigh: {
ET.WARNING: Alert(
"Speed Too High",
"Model uncertain at this speed",
AlertStatus.userPrompt, AlertSize.mid,
Priority.HIGH, VisualAlert.steerRequired, AudibleAlert.promptRepeat, 4.),
ET.NO_ENTRY: NoEntryAlert("Slow down to engage"),
},
EventName.vehicleSensorsInvalid: {
ET.IMMEDIATE_DISABLE: ImmediateDisableAlert("Vehicle Sensors Invalid"),
ET.PERMANENT: NormalPermanentAlert("Vehicle Sensors Calibrating", "Drive to Calibrate"),
ET.NO_ENTRY: NoEntryAlert("Vehicle Sensors Calibrating"),
},
EventName.personalityChanged: {
ET.WARNING: personality_changed_alert,
},
# sunnypilot
EventName.lkasEnable: {
ET.ENABLE: EngagementAlert(AudibleAlert.engage),
},
EventName.lkasDisable: {
ET.USER_DISABLE: EngagementAlert(AudibleAlert.disengage),
},
EventName.manualSteeringRequired: {
ET.USER_DISABLE: Alert(
"Automatic Lane Centering is OFF",
"Manual Steering Required",
AlertStatus.normal, AlertSize.mid,
Priority.LOW, VisualAlert.none, AudibleAlert.disengage, 1.),
},
EventName.manualLongitudinalRequired: {
ET.WARNING: Alert(
"Smart/Adaptive Cruise Control: OFF",
"Manual Speed Control Required",
AlertStatus.normal, AlertSize.mid,
Priority.LOW, VisualAlert.none, AudibleAlert.none, 1.),
},
EventName.silentLkasEnable: {
ET.ENABLE: EngagementAlert(AudibleAlert.none),
},
EventName.silentLkasDisable: {
ET.USER_DISABLE: EngagementAlert(AudibleAlert.none),
},
EventName.silentBrakeHold: {
ET.USER_DISABLE: EngagementAlert(AudibleAlert.none),
ET.NO_ENTRY: NoEntryAlert("Brake Hold Active"),
},
EventName.silentWrongGear: {
ET.WARNING: Alert(
"",
"",
AlertStatus.normal, AlertSize.none,
Priority.LOWEST, VisualAlert.none, AudibleAlert.none, 0.),
ET.NO_ENTRY: Alert(
"Gear not D",
"openpilot Unavailable",
AlertStatus.normal, AlertSize.mid,
Priority.LOW, VisualAlert.none, AudibleAlert.none, 0.),
},
EventName.silentReverseGear: {
ET.PERMANENT: Alert(
"Reverse\nGear",
"",
AlertStatus.normal, AlertSize.full,
Priority.LOWEST, VisualAlert.none, AudibleAlert.none, .2, creation_delay=0.5),
ET.NO_ENTRY: NoEntryAlert("Reverse Gear"),
},
EventName.silentDoorOpen: {
ET.WARNING: Alert(
"",
"",
AlertStatus.normal, AlertSize.none,
Priority.LOWEST, VisualAlert.none, AudibleAlert.none, 0.),
ET.NO_ENTRY: NoEntryAlert("Door Open"),
},
EventName.silentSeatbeltNotLatched: {
ET.WARNING: Alert(
"",
"",
AlertStatus.normal, AlertSize.none,
Priority.LOWEST, VisualAlert.none, AudibleAlert.none, 0.),
ET.NO_ENTRY: NoEntryAlert("Seatbelt Unlatched"),
},
EventName.silentParkBrake: {
ET.WARNING: Alert(
"",
"",
AlertStatus.normal, AlertSize.none,
Priority.LOWEST, VisualAlert.none, AudibleAlert.none, 0.),
ET.NO_ENTRY: NoEntryAlert("Parking Brake Engaged"),
},
EventName.controlsMismatchLateral: {
ET.IMMEDIATE_DISABLE: ImmediateDisableAlert("Controls Mismatch: Lateral"),
ET.NO_ENTRY: NoEntryAlert("Controls Mismatch: Lateral"),
},
}
if __name__ == '__main__':
# print all alerts by type and priority
from cereal.services import SERVICE_LIST
from collections import defaultdict
event_names = {v: k for k, v in EventName.schema.enumerants.items()}
alerts_by_type: dict[str, dict[Priority, list[str]]] = defaultdict(lambda: defaultdict(list))
CP = car.CarParams.new_message()
CS = car.CarState.new_message()
sm = messaging.SubMaster(list(SERVICE_LIST.keys()))
for i, alerts in EVENTS.items():
for et, alert in alerts.items():
if callable(alert):
alert = alert(CP, CS, sm, False, 1, log.LongitudinalPersonality.standard)
alerts_by_type[et][alert.priority].append(event_names[i])
all_alerts: dict[str, list[tuple[Priority, list[str]]]] = {}
for et, priority_alerts in alerts_by_type.items():
all_alerts[et] = sorted(priority_alerts.items(), key=lambda x: x[0], reverse=True)
for status, evs in sorted(all_alerts.items(), key=lambda x: x[0]):
print(f"**** {status} ****")
for p, alert_list in evs:
print(f" {repr(p)}:")
print(" ", ', '.join(alert_list), "\n")